Did the Government fall last night?
Nov 25th, 2007 Print this
Mondegreens
Back in the late 80’s, an Australian band called Little Heroes had a song called One Perfect Day, where a lovelorn chap was singing to his girlfriend in far off “Eng-a-land”. There was a line that I always thought was “Did you get a man for last night?” - which I thought was rather liberal of him. Years later I found out it referred to the coal miners’ strike in Thatcher’s Britain and the line was actually “Did the Government fall last niiiiiight?”.
Yes, our government did fall last night, and yes, we are now rather less Liberal. I’ve had a couple of non-Australians ask me what I think about it. Here’s some random musings…which are biased personal impressions rather than anything informational
The Parties
In Australia the two major parties - the conservative Liberals and the more liberal Labor (which tends to represent labourers) - are really rather similar and economically conservative. The Liberals team up with the more conservative Nationals (which aims to represent rural voters) to form the Coalition. Historically the major difference is in:
- industrial relations (Liberal more employer focus)
- support base (Labor traditionally workers and Unions)
John Howard
John Howard was Liberal Prime Ministerfor the last 11 years. He was first elected the year I started school and he’s held the seat for 33 years. With 77% of the vote counted, it looks like he has lost his seat to Maxine McKew. I’m not a great fan of his policies, but I was impressed with his morning habit of a brisk walk (complete with running shoes and bodyguards). His “Go for Growth” slogan turned my stomach - I think we need to focus on reducing consumption and using what we have in a smarter way.
Around the time that Howard was first elected to Bennelong, McKew became a journalist for our national broadcaster, the ABC. She has a reputation for being intelligent and incisive - although last night she made a speech where she refused to claim victory and used rather saccharine tropes - “Sister Catherine the blind 90 year old nun” and “the 9 year old girl who urged her parents to vote for Kevin because “He’s a good Prime Minister for children”. Meh.
Kevin Rudd
Described by one of my twitterfriends last night as “Tin-Tin with grey hair”, Rudd is an ex-diplomat from Queensland and seems like the closest thing to John Howard the Labor party could find - without actually being John Howard.
He has described himself as a Christian Socialist and overtly wants to ensure that God is not commandeered by the conservatives for political purposes. I believe strongly in the separation of church and state and am alarmed at the way religion has crept onto the political agenda worldwide. I’m a bit unsettled by the biases that Rudd may bring to the position.
He seems to be a “steady plodder” who some believe will now implement more radical reforms than hinted at during the electioneering. His acceptance speech last night deliberately touched on many groups of Australians - indigenous, migrant, rural, Union, youth - and he seemed to foreground a more pluralistic society.
Labor promised some big changes which I support-
1. Ratifying the Kyoto protocol
2. Taking Australian troops out of combat positions in IRAQ and moving them to admin positions. (Our troops are still committed there, however, and it doesn’t bring them home
)
3. Repealing Work Choices laws (this is an industrial relations system that eroded some basic workers’ rights)
My electorate - Fremantle
Strangely enough, I was at school for eight years with Melissa Parke, the woman who was elected our new Labor member. I think she’ll do a very good job with integrity and good will - but wonder whether she’ll be worn down by the cynicism of the whole enterprise.
I’m chuffed that the Greens in the Fremantle electorate here received 14% of the vote compared 7% for the entire country.
UPDATE: 25 November - For the polling booth nearest my home, the Greens actually received 25% of the vote. Looking at the list of polling places in Fremantle, I see a similar figure for those around central Freo - although if you cross Stock Road to Samson, it drops to 10%.
Libraries
The Australian Library and Information Association surveyed the major parties before the election. The Labor party response is here, the Coalition response is here.
I’m rather disturbed by the stated Labor policy on internet filtering and libraries:
Labor believes that the Government should do all that it can to protect Australians, and particularly, Australian children from harmful and inappropriate internet content.
To this end, in March 2006, Labor announced its ISP filtering policy. Labor’s ISP filtering policy will require Internet Service Providers to block access to websites that-are listed as by ACMA as containing prohibited content such as child pornography, acts of extreme violence and X-rated material.
ISP filtering under a Rudd Labor government will be applied to all households (unless they choose to opt-out), schools and public internet points accessible by children, such as libraries.
The Australian National Library’s Pandora Project has been archiving online election material, like:
- media, comment and video web sites
- electoral study and research web sites
- House of Representatives election candidate web sites
- interest and lobby group web sites
- political party web sites
- Senate election candidate web sites
Spooky Men
My only regret now the election is over is that the Spooky Men will no longer be flashmobbing to sing Vote the Bastards Out (a song we had to counsel our children not to accidentally sing in the schoolyard at their Nice Posh School ).

Hi Kathryn,
This is a great summary. Your point about Rudd and Howard being similar was greatly parodied by The Chaser’s last week in a segment called iDemocracy and based on the Mac vs PC ads. I recommend you hunt it down.
Howard has been PM since I finished high school. When I started uni as a Murdoch arts student, there was debate and innovation, new ideas and excitement in academia. Under the Liberals Higher Education reforms, I have seen the universities turn into economically-driven degree factories. I am just hoping that Labor, and funding, can help bring culture and the spirit for knowledge back to the environment.
I understand your worry about the ISP filtering - I think the only people who should filter internet content are guardians of the children (I don’t have kids yet so that opinion might change). The Australian population need to make it clear that we don’t need babysitting like we were under the Howard government. I think that policy was put in place to appease the extreme conservatives and I hope (to God?) that they don’t go through with it.
Despite Kevin Rudd being the dork, and Labor being the new Liberal
I still woke up this morning with the feeling that a great weight had lifted off my shoulders, and reading comments on Twitter and online news sites, I realise I’m not the only one. I had planned to immigrate if the Liberals got back in - now I just want out of conservative WA - the West is proudly declaring how we bucked the national trend! Pfft!
Kate
Hi Kate, Thanks. I was going to mention the “Education Revolution”, then decided I didn’t know much about it and it hadn’t influenced my vote anyhow - I just had the vague impression that both parties were madly throwing buckets of money at higher ed.
Twenty three years ago when I finished high school, I found the same thing, and that was on the cusp of a Liberal / Labor changeover - people were wearing ties to classes and I wondered where the cool academic debate in the coffee shops had gone. Unfortunately the Labor government paved the way for the economic policy of the Libs by axing free education and charging high tertiary fees. It will be interesting to see what happens with Voluntary Student Unionism and whether the Labor govt does anything to prop up the Guilds - traditionally a breeding ground for baby Labor pollies.
Agreed about the filtering. If parents aren’t behaving like parents and monitoring their kids’ cultural consumption, then librarians certainly aren’t qualified to pick up the role.